News

UPDATED: Benue North-East Senatorial District: Abuja court affirms Suswam’s victory in Benue APC primary

0

Justice Inyang Ekwo of a Federal High Court sitting in Abuja on Wednesday, declared former Governor of Benue state, Gabriel Suswam, the winner of the All Progressives Congress (APC) senatorial primary election for Benue North-East Senatorial District and ordered the party to forward his name to the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) as its candidate for the 2027 general elections.

The judge in his judgment, held that neither the APC nor the incumbent senator, Emmanuel Udende, who was substituted for Suswam, provided evidence to contradict the result of the primary election monitored by INEC.

He held that the commission’s report established that Suswam won the May 18, 2026, primary election with 131,083 votes, against Udende’s 1,364 votes, adding that neither the party nor the senator tendered a different result to establish that Udende won the exercise.

Justice Ekwo consequently resolved the substantive issues in favour of Suswam and granted the reliefs sought in his suit, marked FHC/ABJ/CS/1470/2026 which was filed after the decision by the APC to replace Suswam with Udende after the party’s Primary Election Appeal Committee reviewed complaints arising from the May primaries and recommended changes to the initial list of candidates.

Despite Suswam’s victory in the primary, the party subsequently forwarded Udende’s name to INEC as its candidate for the senatorial district, prompting the former governor to approach the court to challenge his substitution.

In the suit against the APC, Udende and INEC, Suswam sought court’s declaration affirming him as the valid winner of the primary and an order compelling the party to forward his name to the electoral commission as its duly nominated candidate.

Before determining the substantive issues, Justice Ekwo dismissed the preliminary objections filed by the defendants, who had challenged the court’s jurisdiction to entertain the suit on the grounds that the dispute constitute internal affairs of a political party.

The judge held that the court’s jurisdiction was properly invoked through the documentary evidence presented by Suswam, noting that an aspirant who participated in a party primary could approach the court where he alleged non-compliance with the Electoral Act, the party’s constitution or its guidelines.

He further held that the provisions of the Electoral Act superseded the internal guidelines of a political party in determining compliance with the law.

Justice Ekwo also dismissed the defendants’ argument that Suswam lacked the locus standi (legal right) to institute the action, holding that he had the requisite legal standing as an aspirant who participated in the primary election.

The court equally rejected their argument that the suit was statute-barred, ruling that the preliminary objections lacked merit.

On the substantive dispute, the judge noted that there was no disagreement among the parties that the APC conducted a primary election on May 18, 2026, which was monitored by INEC.

He said the commission’s report, which was tendered before the court, confirmed that Suswam won the exercise with 131,083 votes, while Udende polled 1,364 votes and further observed that, neither the APC nor Udende challenged the authenticity of INEC’s monitoring report or produced another result to contradict the figures contained in it.

“Therefore, the court has no reason not to act on INEC’s report since its probative value has not been diminished. The 1st and 2nd defendants have not tendered any other result of the election which would have proved that it was the 2nd defendant that was the winner of the primary election,” he held.

Justice Ekwo also faulted the APC’s decision to substitute Suswam with Udende based on the report of its Primary Election Appeal Committee.

The judge noted that the committee’s report was dated May 18, 2026, the same day the primary election was conducted, and that, there was no evidence before the court showing that Suswam was given an opportunity to be heard before the decision to replace him was taken.

He consequently held that the action of the appeal committee constituted an abuse of Suswam’s right to fair hearing, adding that, INEC’s evidence corroborated Suswam’s case and that, the APC and Udende failed to establish any basis for rejecting the result of the primary election.

END

Mike Ojo

Supreme Court reserves judgement in Zamfara North Senatorial dispute

Previous article

You may also like

Comments

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

More in News